As the Tennessee Titans look toward the 2025 NFL Draft, the franchise faces a pivotal decision at quarterback. With securing the No. 1 overall pick, the Titans must determine whether to invest in a true franchise signal-caller or address other key positions. While names like Miami Hurricane’s Cam Ward and Penn State linebacker Abdul Carter have drawn attention, selecting Colorado’s Shedeur Sanders would be the best move for the Titans’ long-term success.
Shedeur Sanders: A True Franchise Quarterback
The Titans’ current quarterback situation is murky at best. Will Levis has shown flashes of potential, but he hasn’t solidified himself as the unquestioned leader of the franchise. Tennessee is picking first overall, Levis struggled and the team is undergoing a complete rebuild. In that scenario, Shedeur Sanders provides an immediate answer at the game’s most important position.
Sanders has excelled under the guidance of his father, Deion Sanders, at Colorado, demonstrating elite poise, arm talent, and football IQ. In 2024, he threw for over 4100+ yards with a high completion percentage, despite playing behind a struggling offensive line. His ability to read defenses, deliver accurate throws, and perform in high-pressure situations makes him an ideal fit for a Titans offense that desperately needs stability.
Additionally, Sanders brings a unique leadership quality that could transform the Titans’ locker room. He carries himself with confidence and professionalism that resembles top-tier NFL quarterbacks, making him an asset both on and off the field.
Why Not Cam Ward?
Cam Ward has impressed at Washington State and Miami, showcasing a dynamic play style with a strong arm and mobility. However, questions remain about his consistency and ability to transition to an NFL system. Ward tends to hold onto the ball too long.
While Ward has high upsides, he is less polished as a pure passer than Sanders. His decision-making and mechanics still need refinement, making him a riskier prospect at No. 1 overall. If the Titans are looking for a plug-and-play quarterback, Sanders is the better choice.
Why Not Abdul Carter?
Abdul Carter is a phenomenal linebacker prospect from Penn State, often compared to Micah Parsons due to his athleticism and pass-rushing ability. However, drafting a defensive player first overall—especially an off-ball linebacker—is rarely the best strategy for a team that lacks a long-term answer at quarterback.
The Titans already have foundational defensive pieces, including Jeffery Simmons and T’Vondre Sweat. While adding a playmaker like Carter would bolster the defense, it wouldn’t address the team’s biggest need: finding an elite quarterback to lead the franchise for the next decade.
The Future of the Titans with Shedeur Sanders
If the Titans land Shedeur Sanders, they immediately gain a quarterback who can elevate the team’s offensive production. Pairing him with playmakers like Calvin Ridley (if he remains on the roster), Chig Okonkwo and Tyjae Spears could create an exciting young core.
Additionally, Tennessee could use the rest of its draft capital to strengthen the offensive line and add defensive depth. With the AFC becoming increasingly competitive, having a quarterback who can go toe-to-toe with Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, Joe Burrow, and C.J. Stroud is crucial.
Shedeur Sanders is not just a good pick—he is the right pick. His skill set, leadership, and potential make him the best option for the Titans at No. 1 overall. While Cam Ward and Abdul Carter are talented players, neither offers the immediate impact and long-term stability that Sanders brings. If Tennessee wants to build a championship-caliber team, it starts with selecting Shedeur Sanders as the face of the franchise.
